This is probably the hardest movie I’ve ever tried to review.
I can totally understand someone seeing this movie and hating it. I mean, not just hating but possibly walking out of it.
The movie is not perfect. Some of the script is hokey and some, you can argue alot, of the movie is conceptually silly.
But I loved this movie.
I think I loved this movie more than this movie was actually good.
I see (I think) what Darren Aronofsky was trying to achieve. This movie is grand and ambitious. The cinematography was amazing and you would expect no less.
I think what it comes down to is how you feel about the 26th-century parts of the movie. The present day and the 16th-century Spain are pretty straightforward when all is said and done. But the future, much like life, is definitely left up to interpretation. At first, I thought it was a metaphor and then I thought it was real but as the credits rolled, I didn’t know what to think. It didn’t take away from how I felt about the movie.
Hugh Jackman was amazing in this film. He really carried this movie alternating pain and passion for his “quest”. I think he should be nominated for an Oscar but the critical reception this movie has gotten might hinder that cause. Brad Pitt was originally cast as he lead until he dropped out. I don’t know if he could have done what Jackman did but it would have been interesting to see him try.
In my heart, I want to give this movie but I cannot deny its imperfections.
This is one of those movies I wouldn’t recommend or at least I would selectively recommend because it’s not easily accessible and requires an OPEN mind. Regardless, you are unlikely to see a movie like it in a long time.